From: Derek on
On Sat, 28 Jun 2008 15:08:32 -0700 (PDT), Rupert <rupertmccallum(a)yahoo.com> wrote:
>On Jun 28, 2:47 am, Derek <usenet.em...(a)gmail.com> wrote:
>>
>> Spain is to become the first country to extend legal
>> rights to apes, wrongfooting animal rights activists
>> who have long campaigned against bullfighting in the
>> country.
>>
>> In what is thought to be the first time a national
>> legislature has granted such rights to animals, the
>> Spanish parliament�s environmental committee voted
>> to approve resolutions committing the country to the
>> Great Apes Project, designed by scientists and
>> philosophers who say that humans� closest biological
>> relatives also deserve rights.
>>
>> The resolution, adopted with crossparty support, calls
>> on the Government to promote the Great Apes Project
>> internationally and ensure the protection of apes from
>> �abuse, torture and death�. �This is a historic moment in
>> the struggle for animal rights,� Pedro Pozas, the Spanish
>> director of the Great Apes Project, told The Times. �It
>> will doubtless be remembered as a key moment in the
>> defence of our evolutionary comrades.�
>> http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/europe/article4220884.ece
>
>Yes, I saw that.

Yes, but did you see it coming? I didn't.

>It's a very encouraging development. I think the
>Great Ape Project is a very promising strategy.

The species barrier has been bust wide open. The
speciesist who attempts to deny rights to animals on
the basis of petty prejudice and discrimination can
no longer argue that humans, by dint of being human,
are the only animal on this earth legally entitled to hold
basic rights against other humans. He has failed to make
the case that while membership to group x morally and
legally entitles members to hold rights against other
members of that group, membership to another group
automatically excludes them as rights holders against
those members in group x.

>Many chimpanzees, gorillas, and orang-utans will now be protected from
>abuse, which is excellent.

And, while apes hold legal rights against humans, those
against the proposition of extending them further must
show the morally relevant difference between them and
the apes that now hold them.

This is huge!